Writing $1 Million New Premium Per Month

The Insurance Guys - Dec 24, 2025

On this episode, Scott Howell and Bradley Flowers welcome Shelby Tirado and Chris Huebener from Brightway Insurance in Jacksonville, FL. The crew explores the agency’s impressive operations, including a high-volume new business model that writes about $1 million in new premium each month and has a network of over 600 referral partners. Shelby Tirado and Chris Huebener share insights from their restaurant industry backgrounds that translate into insurance success, such as multitasking, energy, and customer service. The episode covers Brightway’s unique approach to onboarding, producer development, and referral partner management, all fueling their strong growth. They discuss strategies for staying top-of-mind with referral sources, adapting in a tough Florida market, and why hiring outside the insurance industry can be a game-changer. Whether you want to scale your agency or refine your process, this episode is packed with actionable wisdom from top performers.

Podcast Page